ASSESSMENT OF THE RISK OF MEDICAL ERRORS OF DOCTORS OF DIFFERENT PROFILES OF THE EASTERN KAZAKHSTAN REGION
Relevance. From a medical point of view, “medical error” is the impossibility of carrying out the necessary diagnosis or treatment within the framework of the clinical protocol for objective and subjective reasons. It is important to note that a large proportion of medical errors occur not because of the low professionalism of medical workers, but because of a failure in communication between doctors and patients and conflicts between them, therefore, the study of the risks of medical errors always remains relevant. The aim of the study: to assess the risks of medical errors of doctors of different profiles of the East Kazakhstan region. Materials and research methods. We analyzed the current legislation in the field of healthcare, as well as the annual reports of the Department for Quality Control and Safety of Goods and Services of the East Kazakhstan region (DQCSGS EKR) for the period 2014-2018. Research results. As a result of the analysis of the annual reports of the (DQCSGS EKR) in the context of the specialties, it was revealed that in the appeals of individuals and legal entities for 2014-2018, the leading positions are held by examinations involving physicians - 199 cases (23,69%), surgeons 149 cases (17,74%) and obstetrician-gynecologists 115 (13,69%). Specialists: neuropathologists, neonatologists, and traumatologists were also often enough involved in conducting examinations - in 96 (11,43%), 58 (6,90%), 46 (5,48%) cases, respectively. Moreover, in all sections there are a large number of appeals for “poor-quality treatment”, “the validity of issuing a certificate of incapacity for work”, “violation of ethical and deontological standards”. It is worth noting that a larger number of examinations were recognized as “unfounded” in the verdict of an expert doctor, while “substantiated” and “partially justified” appeals of individuals and legal entities were registered in equal shares. Conclusion. Thus, as a result of the study, it was found that the greatest attention is required for patients receiving therapeutic and surgical care both at the inpatient and outpatient levels. The quality of the services provided and the reasonable issuance of disability certificates should be monitored in medical institutions in several stages, which will reduce the number of requests for these reasons. Ethics and deontology, a topical issue in all specialties, periodic preventive discussions, trainings or trainings with the involvement of psychologists or psychotherapists at each stage of the work of medical institutions will help to establish a process of interaction and satisfy all patient expectations.
Olga Andreyeva 1, http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2802-9441 Tasbolat Adylkhanov 1, http://orcid.org/0000-0002-9092-5060 Aidana Rakhmankulova 1, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3307-413X Zhansaya Uagyzkhankyzy 1, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0240-0097 Elizaveta Sayapina, Madina Kabykenova, Kamila Ergaliyeva, Assem Assemzhanova, Zhadyra Boranbayeva, Tolganai Tursymbayeva, Aizhan Kaldykulova, Dana Kamadanova 1 Semey Medical University, Semey, Republic of Kazakhstan.
1. Багмет А.М., Черкасова Л.И. Тактика и методика расследования причинения смерти по неосторожности вследствие ненадлежащего исполнения медицинскими работниками своих профессиональных обязанностей. Учебное пособие,– 2013. – 139 с. 2. Баринов Е.Х. и др. Юридическая квалификация дефектов оказания медицинской помощи и врачебных ошибок - помощь практическому здравоохранению // Медицинское право. 2010. №. 5. С. 3-8. 3. Батюкова В.Е. за Об ответственности ошибки врачей за служба допущенные ошибки //кадры Государственная служба и кадры. 2019. №. 1. С. 108-110 4. Варданян Г.Д. и др. Врачебные ошибки: современное состояние проблемы // Армянская медицина. 2019. Т. 59. №. 4. С. 105-120. 5. Зарецкий М.М., Черникова Н.М. Врачебная ошибка: невежество или халатность? // Новости медицины и фармации. 1-2 (267-268) 2009. – № 2. 6. Ибатулина Ю.Ф. Ненадлежащее исполнение профессиональных обязанностей медицинскими работниками и врачебная ошибка: уголовно-правовой аспект // Российский следователь. 2010. №.1. С.12. 7. Костикова Е.О. Возмещение вреда, причиненного жизни или здоровью граждан вследствие медицинской ошибки. М.: НОУ ВПО «ИМПиЭ им. А.С. Грибоедова. 2009. –11 с. 8. Кравченко Л.М. Проблемы коммуникации в медицине как ведущая причина врачебных ошибок // Colloquium - journal. – Голопристанський міськрайонний центр зайнятості, 2019. №. 7. 31 с. 9. Лопатина Т.М. Профессиональная ошибка в условиях функционирования право цифровой медицины // Российское право: Образование. Практика. Наука. 2019. №. 5. С. 68-74. 10. Панков А.А., Исаев А.А., Ермолаева Е.В. Риски в медицине. Бюллетень медицинских интернет-конференций. – Общество с ограниченной ответствен-ностью «Наука и инновации», 2015. Т.5. №.12. 1568 с. 11. Сергеев Ю.Д., Козлов С.В. Основные виды дефектов оказания медицинской помощи (по данным комиссионных судебно-медицинских экспертиз) // Медицинское право. 2012. №. 3. С. 35-38. 12. Субботина Е.В. Критерии установления пределов осуществления субъективных гражданских прав // Вестник Магнитогорского государственного технического университета им. ГИ Носова. 2010. №.3. С. 24-28. 13. Субботина Е.В. Характеристика шиканы как формы злоупотребления правом // Юрист. 2013. №.5. С. 37-40. 14. Султанов И.Я. Некоторые этические и правовые аспекты в проблемы врачебных ошибок в свете истории медицины // Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Медицина. 2001. №.1. С. 54-60. 15. Сучков А.В. Анализ дефиниций понятия "врачебная ошибка", с целью формулирования определения "профессиональные преступления медицинских работников" // Медицинское право. 2010. №. 5. С. 45-50. 16. Сучкова Т.Е., Семенов А.В. О юридической ответственности медицинских работников при совершении ими профессиональных правонарушений // Вестник Вятского государственного университета. 2011. №. 2-1. С. 91-98. 17. Тихомиров А.В. Проблемы правовой квалификации вреда здоровью при оказании медицинских услуг. Автореф. канд. диссерт. 2008. 180 с. 18. Тузлукова М.В. Актуальные вопросы расследо-вания ятрогенных преступлений // Вестник Московского университета МВД России. 2012. №.11. 35с. 19. Battard J. Nonpunitive response to errors fosters a just culture // Nursing management. 2017. Vol. 48. №. 1. pp. 53-55. 20. Becher E.C., Chassin M.R. Improving quality, minimizing error: making it happen // Health Affairs. 2001. Vol. 20. №. 3. pp. 68-81. 21. Bouldin E.D. et al. Falls among adult patients hospitalized in the United States: prevalence and trends // Journal of patient safety. 2013. Vol. 9. №. 1. p. 13. 22. Delacroix R. Exploring the experience of nurse practitioners who have committed medical errors: A phenomenological approach // Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners. 2017. Vol. 29. №. 7. pp. 403-409. 23. Donaldson M.S. et al. (ed.). To err is human: building a safer health system. – National Academies Press, 2000. Vol. 6. pp. 27 – 32. 24. Helo S., Moulton C.A. Complications: acknowledging, managing, and coping with human error // Translational andrology and urology. 2017. Vol. 6. №. 4. p. 773. 25. Hines S., Kynoch K., Khalil H. Effectiveness of interventions to prevent medication errors: an umbrella systematic review protocol // JBI database of systematic reviews and implementation reports. 2018. Vol. 16. №. 2. pp. 291-296. 26. James J.T. A new, evidence-based estimate of patient harms associated with hospital care // Journal of patient safety. 2013. Vol. 9. №. 3. pp. 122-128. 27. Kellogg K.M. et al. Our current approach to root cause analysis: is it contributing to our failure to improve patient safety? // BMJ quality & safety. 2017. Vol. 26. №. 5. – pp. 381-387. 28. Mascioli S., Carrico C.B. Spotlight on the 2016 national patient safety goals for hospitals // Nursing 2020 Critical Care. 2016. Vol. 11. №. 6. pp. 19-22. 29. Oyebode F. Clinical errors and medical negligence // Medical Principles and Practice. 2013. Vol. 22. №.4. pp. 323-333. 30. Palojoki S. et al. Electronic health record-related safety concerns: a cross-sectional survey of electronic health record users // JMIR medical informatics. 2016. Vol. 4. №. 2. p. 13. 31. Revelas A. Healthcare–associated infections: A public health problem // Nigerian medical journal: journal of the Nigeria Medical Association. 2012. Vol. 53. №. 2. p. 59. 32. Robertson J.J., Long B. Suffering in silence: medical error and its impact on health care providers // The Journal of emergency medicine. 2018. Vol. 54. №. 4. pp. 402-409. 33. Saleem A. M. et al. Initial assessment of patient handoff in accredited general surgery residency programs in the United States and Canada: a cross-sectional survey // Canadian Journal of Surgery. 2015. Vol. 58. №. 4. p. 269. 34. Singh H. et al. The global burden of diagnostic errors in primary care // BMJ quality & safety. 2017. Vol. 26. №. 6. pp. 484-494. 35. Tarrac S.E. Medical Error and Harm: Understanding, Prevention, and Control // Aorn Journal. 2011. Vol. 4. №. 93. p. 513. 36. Wolf Z.R. et al. Nursing student medication errors involving tubing and catheters: A descriptive study // Nurse Education Today. 2009. Vol. 29. №. 6. pp. 681-688. References 1. Bagmet A.M., Cherkasova L.I. Taktika i metodika rassledovaniya prichineniya smerti po neostorozhnosti vsledstvie nenadlezhashchego ispolneniya meditsinskimi rabotnikami svoikh professional'nykh obyazannostei [Tactics and methods of investigation of death caused by negligence due to improper performance by medical workers of their professional duties]. Uchebnoe posobie [Tutorial], 139 p. – 2013. – p. 58 [in Russian]. 2. Barinov E.H. i dr. Yuridicheskaya kvalifikatsiya defektov okazaniya meditsinskoi pomoshchi i vrachebnykh oshibok - pomosch' prakticheskomu zdravookhraneniyu [Legal qualification of defects in the provision of medical care and medical errors - assistance to practical health care]. Meditsinskoe pravo [Medical law]. 2010. №. 5. pp. 3-8 [in Russian]. 3. Batyukova V.E. Ob otvetstvennosti vrachei za dopuschennye oshibki [About the responsibility of doctors' mistakes for the service made mistakes]. Gosudarstvennaya sluzhba i kadry [Civil service and personnel]. 2019. №. 1. pp. 108-110 [in Russian]. 4. Vardanyan G.D. i dr. Vrachebnye oshibki: sovremennoe sostoyanie problem [Medical errors: current state of the problem]. Armyanskaya meditsina [Armenian medicine]. 2019. Vol. 59. №. 4. pp. 105-120 [in Russian]. 5. Zareckij M.M., Chernikova N.M. Vrachebnaya oshibka: nevezhestvo ili khalatnost'? [Medical error: ignorance or negligence?]. Novosti meditsiny i farmatsii. (News of Medicine and Pharmacy]. 1-2 (267-268) 2009. – №. 2 [in Russian]. 6. Ibatulina Yu.F. Nenadlezhaschee ispolnenie professional'nykh obyazannostei meditsinskimi rabotnikami i vrachebnaya oshibka: ugolovno-pravovoi aspect [Improper performance of professional duties by health workers and medical error: criminal law aspect]. Rossijskii sledovatel' [Russian investigator]. 2010. №. 1. p. 12 [in Russian]. 7. Kostikova E.O. Vozmeschenie vreda, prichinennogo zhizni ili zdorov'yu grazhdan vsledstvie medicinskoi oshibki [Compensation for harm caused to the life or health of citizens as a result of a know-how of a medical error]. M.: NOU VPO «IMPiE im. A.S. Griboedova. 2009. p.11 [in Russian]. 8. Kravchenko L.M. Problemy kommunikatsii v meditsine kak vedushchaya prichina vrachebnykh oshibok [Communication problems in medicine as a leading cause of medical errors]. Colloquium-journal. – Golopristans'kii mіs'kraionnii centr zanyatostі [Colloquium-journal. - Holopristansky mіs'krajonnij center zajnyatostі], 2019. №. 7 p. 31 [in Russian]. 9. Lopatina T.M. Professional'naya oshibka v usloviyakh funktsionirovaniya tsifrovoi meditsiny [Professional error in the functioning of digital medicine]. Rossiiskoe pravo: Obrazovanie. Praktika. Nauka [Russian law: Education. Practice. The science]. 2019. №. 5. pp. 68-74 [in Russian]. 10. Pankov A.A., Isaev A.A., Ermolaeva E.V. Riski v meditsine [Risks in medicine]. Byulleten' meditsinskikh internet-konferencii. – Obschestvo s ogranichennoi otvetstvennost'yu «Nauka i innovatsii» [Limited Liability Company "Science and Innovations"], 2015. Vol. 5. №. 12. – 1568 [in Russian]. 11. Sergeev Yu.D., Kozlov S.V. Osnovnye vidy defektov okazaniya meditsinskoi pomoschi (po dannym komissionnykh sudebno-meditsinskikh ekspertiz) [The main types of defects in the provision of medical care (according to Commission forensic medical examinations]. Meditsinskoe parvo [Medical law]. 2012. №. 3. pp. 35-38 [in Russian]. 12. Subbotina E.V. Kriterii ustanovleniya predelov osushchestvleniya sub"ektivnykh grazhdanskikh prav [Criteria for setting limits on the exercise of subjective civil rights]. Vestnik Magnitogorskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta im. G.I. Nosova [Bulletin of the Magnitogorsk State Technical University G.I. Nosova]. 2010. №. 3. pp. 24-28 [in Russian]. 13. Subbotina E.V. Kharakteristika shikany kak formy zloupotrebleniya pravom [Characteristic of chicanes as a form of abuse of law]. Yurist [Lawyer]. 2013. №. 5. pp. 37-40. [in Russian]. 14. Sultanov I.Ya. Nekotorye aspekty eticheskikh i vrachebnykh pravovykh aspekty v problemy vrachebnykh istorii oshibok v svete istorii universiteta mediciny [Some aspects of ethical and medical legal aspects in the problem of medical history of errors in the journal of medical history of the University of medicine]. Vestnik narodov Rossiiskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. Seriya: Meditsina [Bulletin of the peoples of the Peoples' Friendship University of Russia. Series: Medicine]. 2001. №. 1. pp. 54-60 [in Russian]. 15. Suchkov A.V. Analiz definitsii ponyatiya "vrachebnaya oshibka", s tsel'yu formulirovaniya opredeleniya "professional'nye prestupleniya meditsinskikh rabotnikov" [Analysis of definitions of the concept "medical error", in order to formulate the definition of "professional crimes of medical workers"]. Meditsinskoe pravo [Medical law]. 2010. №. 5. pp. 45-50 [in Russian]. 16. Suchkova T.E., Semeno A.V. O yuridicheskoi otvetstvennosti meditsinskikh rabotnikov pri sovershenii imi professional'nykh pravonarushenii [About legal liability of medical workers when they commit professional offenses]. Vestnik Vyatskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Vyatka State University Bulletin]. 2011. №. 2-1. pp. 91-98. [in Russian]. 17. Tihomirov A.V. Problemy pravovoi kvalifikatsii vreda zdorov'yu pri okazanii meditsinskikh uslug [Problems of legal qualification of harm to health in the provision of medical services]. Kand. dissertat [Cand. Dissertate.] – 2008. – 160 p. [in Russian] 18. Tuzlukova M.V. Aktual'nye voprosy rassledovaniya yatrogennykh prestuplenii [Topical issues of investigation of iatrogenic crimes]. Vestnik Moskovskogo str universiteta MVD Rossii [Bulletin of the Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia]. 2012. №.11. - pp. 35 [in Russian]. 19. Battard J. Nonpunitive response to errors fosters a just culture. Nursing management. 2017. Vol. 48. №.1. pp. 53-55. 20. Becher E.C., Chassin M.R. Improving quality, minimizing error: making it happen. Health Affairs. 2001. Vol. 20. №.3. pp. 68-81. 21. Bouldin E.D. et al. Falls among adult patients hospitalized in the United States: prevalence and trends. Journal of patient safety. 2013. Vol. 9. №. 1. 13 p. 22. Delacroix R. Exploring the experience of nurse practitioners who have committed medical errors: A phenomenological approach. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners. 2017. Vol. 29. №.7. pp. 403-409. 23. Donaldson M.S. et al. To err is human: building a safer health system. – National Academies Press, 2000. – Vol. 6. pp. 27 – 32. 24. Helo S., Moulton C.A. Complications: acknowledging, managing, and coping with human error. Translational andrology and urology. 2017. Vol. 6. №.4. p. 773. 25. Hines S., Kynoch K., Khalil H. Effectiveness of interventions to prevent medication errors: an umbrella systematic review protocol. JBI database of systematic reviews and implementation reports. 2018. Vol. 16. №. 2. pp. 291-296. 26. James J.T. A new, evidence-based estimate of patient harms associated with hospital care. Journal of patient safety. 2013. Vol. 9. №. 3. pp. 122-128. 27. Kellogg K.M. et al. Our current approach to root cause analysis: is it contributing to our failure to improve patient safety? BMJ quality & safety. 2017. Vol. 26. №. 5. pp. 381-387. 28. Mascioli S., Carrico C. B. Spotlight on the 2016 national patient safety goals for hospitals. Nursing. 2020 Critical Care. 2016. Vol. 11. №. 6. pp. 19-22. 29. Oyebode F. Clinical errors and medical negligence // Medical Principles and Practice. 2013. Vol. 22. №. 4. pp. 323-333. 30. Palojoki S. et al. Electronic health record-related safety concerns: a cross-sectional survey of electronic health record users. JMIR medical informatics. 2016. Vol. 4. №. 2. p. 13. 31. Revelas A. Healthcare–associated infections: A public health problem. Nigerian medical journal: journal of the Nigeria Medical Association. 2012. Vol. 53. №. 2. p. 59. 32. Robertson J.J., Long B. Suffering in silence: medical error and its impact on health care providers. The Journal of emergency medicine. 2018. Vol. 54. №. 4. pp. 402-409. 33. Saleem A.M. et al. Initial assessment of patient handoff in accredited general surgery residency programs in the United States and Canada: a cross-sectional survey. Canadian Journal of Surgery. 2015. Vol. 58. №. 4. p. 269. 34. Singh H. et al. The global burden of diagnostic errors in primary care. BMJ quality & safety. 2017. Vol. 26. №. 6. pp. 484-494. 35. Tarrac S.E. Medical Error and Harm: Understanding, Prevention, and Control. Aorn Journal. 2011. Vol. 4. №. 93. p. 513. 36. Wolf Z. R. et al. Nursing student medication errors involving tubing and catheters: A descriptive study. Nurse Education Today. 2009. Vol. 29. №. 6. pp. 681-688.
Number of Views: 218

Key words:

Bibliography link

Andreyeva O., Adylkhanov T., Rakhmankulova A., Uagyzkhankyzy Zh., Sayapina E., Kabykenova M., Ergaliyeva K., Assemzhanova A., Boranbayeva Zh., Tursymbayeva T., Kaldykulova A., Kamadanova D. Assessment of the risk of medical errors of doctors of different profiles of the Eastern Kazakhstan region // Nauka i Zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2020, (Vol.22) 3, pp. 105-118. doi 10.34689/SH.2020.22.4.011

Авторизируйтесь для отправки комментариев