RISK OF DISORDERS OF NONSPECIFIC RESISTANCE DUE TO LONG-TERM EXPOSURE TO RADIATION IN SMALL DOSES
Background: long-term exposure to ionizing radiation in small doses on the human body is manifested by violations of the adaptive response of regulatory systems to stress.
Aim: to perform a systematic search of valid scientific data in order to assess the disorders of nonspecific resistance in the human organism due to long-term exposure to radiation in small doses
Materials and methods. The search for scientific publications was carried out in the evidence-based medicine’s databases (PubMed, Cochrane Library, ResearchGate, Google Scholar) and in the electronic scientific libraries (CyberLeninka). A total of 312 literary sources were found, 46 articles were selected for further analysis.
Results: the relevant scientific papers found in electronic databases are characterized by the marked heterogeneity. Most of the published studies belong to the category of cross-sectional, we could also find a small amount of cohort studies and unsystematic literature reviews.
Conclusion: Literary sources in the studied field found in various databases allow us to define a certain pattern of development of effects of small doses of radiation to the regulatory systems of the human organism. Studies carried out in Kazakhstan require further development and continuation due to the fact that until now large populations continue to live in ecologically unfavorable territories.
Lyudmila M. Pivina 1,
Yuliya M. Semenova 1, http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1324-7806
Тatyana I. Belikhina 1,
Аlmira М. Manatova 1,
Altaj A. Dyussupov 1, http://orcid.org/0000-0003-0875-1020
Nurlan Ye. Aukenov 2
Semey State Medical University, Semey, Kazakhstan
Bychkovskaya I.B., Stepanov R.P., Fedortseva R.F. Osobye dolgovremennye izmeneniya kletok pri vozdeistvii radiatsii v malykh dozakh [Specific long-term changes at small doses radiation exposure]. Radiatsiya. Biologiya. Radioekologiya [Radiation. Biology. Radioecology]. 2002. T. 42, № 1. pp. 20–35. [in Russian].
Vlasenko M.A., Kulinich V.S. Osobennosti syvorotochnogo lipidnogo profilya u patsientov s tireoidnoi patologiei, professional'no kontaktiruyushhikh s ioniziruyushhei radiatsiei v malykh dozakh [Features of serum lipid profile in patients with thyroid pathology, professionally contacting with ionizing radiation in small doses]. Klinicheskaya meditsina [Clinical Medicine]. 2014, №2. pp. 38-43. [in Russian].
Goncharova R.I., Smolich I.I. Geneticheskaya effektivnost' malykh doz ionizirujushhei radiatsii pri khronicheskom obluchenii melkikh mlekopitayushhikh [Genetic efficacy of small doses of ionizing radiation in chronic irradiation of small mammals]. Radiatsiya. Biologiya. Radioekologiya [Radiation. Biology. Radioecology]. 2002. T. 42, № 6. pp.654–660. [in Russian].
Goncharenko E.N., Antonova S.V., Akhalaja M.Ya., Kudryashov Yu.B. Vliyanie malykh doz ioniziruyushhei radiatsii na uroven' soderzhaniya katekholaminov i kortikosteroidov v nadpochechnikakh myshei [Influence of small doses of ionizing radiation on the level of catecholamines and corticosteroids in the adrenal glands of mice]. Radiatsiya. Biologiya. Radioekologiya [Radiation. Biology. Radioecology]. 2000. T. 40, №2. pp.160–161. [in Russian].
Greib R. Deistvie malykh doz ioniziruyjushhego izlucheniya: Effekt Petko [Effects of small doses of ionizing radiation: The Petko effect]. Yadernaya entsiklopediya. M., 1996. pp.387–394. [in Russian].
Grzhibovskij A.M., Ivanov S.V. Poperechnye (odnomomentnye) issledovaniya v zdravookhranenii [Cross-sectional (one-stage) studies in health care system]. Nauka i zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare] . 2015, №2. S. 5-18. [in Russian].
Grzhibovskij A.M., Ivanov S.V., Gorbatova M.A. Issledovanija tipa «sluchaj-kontrol'» v zdravoohranenii (Case-control studies in health care system). Nauka i zdravoohranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2015, №4. pp. 5-17. [in Russian].
Dudareva Yu.A., Gur'eva V.A. Otsenka sostoyaniya shhitovidnoi zhelezy u zhenshhin, nakhodivshihsya v zone radiatsionnogo vozdeijstviya, i ikh potomkov v dvukh pokoleniyakh [Evaluation of the state of the thyroid gland in women living in the radiation exposure zone and their descendants in two generations]. Ekologiya cheloveka [Human Ecology]. 2015, №10. pp. 9-13. [in Russian].
Espenbetova M.Zh., Zamanbekova Zh.K., Uvataeva Zh.S., Sarsebaeva G.S., Shaikhina A.T., Sembaeva G.K., Taratutina O.V. Sostoyanie shhitovidnoi zhelezy u naseleniya raionov, prilegayushhikh k byvshemu semipalatinskomu ispytatel'nomu yadernomu poligonu [The state of the thyroid gland in the population of the areas adjacent to the former Semipalatinsk nuclear test site]. Nauka i zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2014, №5. pp. 28-32. [in Russian].
Ivanovskii Yu.A. Radiatsionnyi gormezis. Blagopriyatny li malye dozy ioniziruyushhei radiatsii? [Radiation hormesis. Are small doses of ionizing radiation favorable?] Vestnik Dal'nevostochnogo otdeleniya Rossiiskoi akademii nauk [Bulletin of the Far Eastern Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. 2006, №6. pp. 86-91. [in Russian].
Kandror V.I. Molekulyarno-geneticheskie aspekty tireoidnoi patologii [Molecular-genetic aspects of thyroid pathology]. Problemy endokrinologii [Problems of endocrinology]. 2001. T. 47, № 5. pp. 3-10. [in Russian].
Kienya A.I., Mel'nik V.A. Status vegetativnoi nervnoi sistemy sel'skikh detei Gomel'skogo regiona v postchernobyl'skii period [Status of the autonomic nervous system of rural children in the Gomel region in the post-Chernobyl period]. Problemy zdorov'ya i ekologii [Problems of health and ecology]. 2004. № 1. pp. 30–34. [in Russian].
Kostryukova N.K., Karpin V.A. Biologicheskie effekty malykh doz ioniziruyushhego izlucheniya [Biological effects of low doses of ionizing radiation]. Sibirskii meditsinskii zhurnal (Irkutsk) [Siberian Medical Journal (Irkutsk)]. 2005, №4. pp. 17-22. [in Russian].
Naumova G.I. Vliyanie malykh doz ioniziruyushhei radiatsii na vegetativnuyu sistemu cheloveka [Influence of small doses of ionizing radiation on the human vegetative system]. Zdravookhranenie [Health care]. 1999. № 1. pp. 31–33. [in Russian].
Paramonova N.S. Lyalikov S.A. Autoimmunitet i gormonal'nyi status u detei iz ekologicheski neblagopoluchnykh raionov [Autoimmunity and hormonal status in children from ecologically unfavorable areas]. Aktual'nye problemy nauchnogo obespecheniya sanitarno-epidemicheskogo blagopoluchiya naseleniya i puti ikh realizatsii: sbornik materialov Plenuma, Minsk, 27 aprelya 2000 g. Minsk. 2000. pp. 125-126. [in Russian].
Paramonova N.S. Antitiroidnye antitela i patologiya shhitovidnoi zhelezy (obzor literatury) [Antithyroid antibodies and thyroid pathology (literature review)]. Zhurnal GGMU [Journal of the SMU.]. 2005b № 3. pp. 9-11. [in Russian].
Petunina N.A. Osobennosti terapii zabolevanij shhitovidnoi zhelezy u patsientov s kardial'noi patologiei [Features of therapy of thyroid diseases in patients with cardiac pathology]. Russkii medicinskii zhurnal [Russian Medical Journal]. 2005, № 13 (28). pp. 1927-1932. [in Russian].
Pelevina I.I., Aleshhenko A.V., Antoshhina M.M. Reaktsiya populyatsii kletok na obluchenie v malykh dozakh [The reaction of a population of cells to irradiation in small doses]. Radiatsiya. Biologiya. Radioekologiya [Radiation. Biology. Radioecology]. 2003. T. 43, № 2. pp.161–166. [in Russian].
Pivina L.M., Belikhina T.I Optimizatsiya lecheniya arterial'noi gipertenzii pri gipotireoze u lits, podvergshikhsya radiatsionnomu vozdeistvii [Optimization of the treatment of arterial hypertension in hypothyroidism in persons exposed to radiation]. Meditsina i farmakologiya: elektronnyi nauchnyi zhurnal [Medicine and pharmacology: electronic scientific journal]. 2014. № 3 (4). [in Russian].
Pivina L.M., Batenova G.B., Kurumbaev R.R., Kerimkulova A.S., Markabaeva A.M., Kaskabaeva A.Sh. Kharakteristika komorbidnoi endokrinnoi i serdechno-sosudistoi patologii u potomkov lits, podvergshihsya radiatsionnomu vozdeistviyu [Characteristics of comorbid endocrine and cardiovascular pathology in descendants of persons exposed to radiation]. Nauka i zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2013, №3. pp. 13-19. [in Russian].
Safonova V.Ju., Safonova V.A. Biologicheskoe vliyanie malykh doz radiatsii, aspekty bezopasnosti [Biological impact of small doses of radiation, safety aspects]. Izvestiya Orenburgskogo gosudarstvennogo agrarnogo universiteta [Proceedings of the Orenburg State Agrarian University]. 2011. T.3, №1. pp. 308-310. [in Russian].
Suskov I.I., Kuz'mina N.S. Problema indutsirovannoi genomnoi nestabil'nosti v detskom organizme v usloviyakh dlitel'nogo deistviya malykh doz radiatsii [The problem of induced genomic instability in the child's organism under the long-term effect of small doses of radiation]. Radiatsiya. Biologiya. Radioekologiya [Radiation. Biology. Radioecology]. 2003. T. 43, № 2. pp.150–152. [in Russian].
Cyb A.F., Matveenko E.G., Nestaiko G.V., Gorobec V.F. Postradiatsionnyi gipotireoz (nauchnyi obzor) [Post-radiation hypothyroidism (scientific review)]. Radiatsiya i risk [Radiation and Risk].1997, №10. pp. 61-83. [in Russian].
Cyb A.F., Matveenko E.G., Gorobets V.F., Borovikova M.P., Temnikova E.I., Gorobets N.Ja. Dinamika morfofunktsional'nogo sostoyaniya shhitovidnoi zhelezy u vnutriutrobno obluchennykh detei iz yugo-zapadnogo regiona Kaluzhskoij oblasti v techenie pervogo desyatiletiya posle chernobyl'skoi avarii [Dynamics of the morphofunctional state of the thyroid gland in intra-uterine exposed children from the southwestern region of the Kaluga region during the first decade after the Chernobyl accident]. Radiatsiya i risk [Radiation and Risk]. 2001, № 12. pp. 42-47. [in Russian].
Cheshik I.A., Nikonovich S.N., Mel'nov S.B. Antropometricheskii i endokrinnyi status devochek 9–13 let, prozhivayushhikh v chernobyl'skikh regionakh Gomel'skoi oblasti [Anthropometric and endocrine status of girls i-13 years living in the Chernobyl regions of the Gomel region]. Problemy zdorov'ya i ekologii [Problems of health and ecology]. 2007. № 3. pp. 83–88. [in Russian].
Cheshik I.A., Shesterina E.K., Kovalenko V.V., Mel'nik V.A. Konstitutsional'nye osobennosti detei i podrostkov, postoyanno prozhivayushhikh v usloviyakh khronicheskogo nizkodozovogo radiatsionnogo vozdeistviya, kak diagnosticheskie kriterii ikh zdorov'ya (obzor literatury) [The constitutional features of children and adolescents permanently living in conditions of chronic low-dose radiation exposure, as diagnostic criteria for their health (literature review)]. Problemy zdorov'ya i ekologii [Problems of health and ecology]. 2011, № 3. pp.32-36. [in Russian].
Yarmonenko S.P. Nizkie urovni izlucheniya i zdorov'e: radiobiologicheskie aspekty [Low levels of radiation and health: radiobiological aspects]. Meditsinskaya radiologiya i radiatsionnaya bezopasnost' [Medical Radiology and Radiation Safety]. 2000. T. 45, № 3. pp. 5–32. [in Russian].
Akleyev AV. Chronic radiation syndrome among residents of the Techa riverside villages. Radiat Prot Dosimetry. 2012. Vol.151(4). Р.689-695.
Spitz D.R., Hauer-Jensen M. Ionizing radiation-induced responses: where free radical chemistry meets redox biology and medicine // Antioxid Redox Signal. 2014. Vol. 20(9). Р.1407-1409.
Azzam E.I., Colangelo N.W., Domogauer J.D., Sharma N., de Toledo S.M. Is ionizing radiation harmful at any exposure? An echo that continues to vibrate. Health Physics. 2016, Vol. 110, Number 3. С. 249-251.
Gencer B., Collet T.H., Virgini V., Bauer D.C., Gussekloo J.,Cappola A.R. et al. Subclinical thyroid dysfunction and the risk of heart failure evens: An individual participant data analysis from 6 prospective cohorts. Circulation. 2012. Vol. 126. Р. 1040—1049.
Groshe B., Land C., Bauer S., Pivina L.M., Abylkassimova Z.N, Gusev B.I. Fallout from nuclear tests: health effects in Kazakhstan. Radiat Environ Biophys. 2002. DOI 10.1007|00411-001-0136-1
Grosche B., Lackland D.T., Land C.E., Simon S.L., Apsalikov K.N., Pivina L.M., Bauer S., Gusev B.I. Mortality from cardiovascular diseases in the Semipalatinsk historical cohort, 1960-1999, and its relationship to radiation exposure. Radiat Res. 2011. Vol. 176, №5. P. 660-669.
Kawano N., Hirabayashi K., Matsuo M., Hiraoka T., Hoshi M., Apsalikov K., Muldagaliev T. Direct Experiences from the Nuclear Explosions in Inhabitants near Semipalatinsk Nuclear Test Site. 13th Hirosima International Symposium. 4th Dosimetry workshop on the Semipalatinsk Nuclear Test Site Area. 2008. P.24.
Klein I., Danzi S. Thyroid disease and the heart. Circulation. 2007. Vol. 116. Р. 1725-1735.
Little MP. A review of non-cancer effects, especially circulatory and ocular diseases. Radiat Environ Biophys. 2013. Vol.52. Р.435–449.
Oganesian N.M., Davidian N.R., Gevorkian E.G., Karapetian A.G., Miridzhanian M.I., Asrian K.V. Delayed medical consequences of the Chernobyl accident in Armenia. Assessment of life quality and accelerated biological aging of accident liquidators. Radiats Biol Radioecol. 2011.Vol.51(1). Р.91-100.
Ostroumova E., Brenner A., Oliynyk V., McConnell R., Robbins J., Terekhova G., Zablotska L., Likhtarev I., Bouville A. and Hatch M., Subclinical hypothyroidism after radioiodine exposure: Ukrainian-American cohort study of thyroid cancer and other thyroid diseases after the Chornobyl accident (1998–2000). Environ. Health Perspect. 2009. Vol.117. Р.745–750.
Pelevina I., Gotlib V., Konradov A. 20 years after Chernobyl accident--is it a lot or not for the estimation its characteristics? Radiats Biol Radioecol. 2006. Vol.46(2). Р.240-247.
Peters K.O., Tronko M., Hatch M., Oliynyk V., Terekhova G., Pfeiffer R.M., Shpak V.M., McConnell R.J., Drozdovitch V., Little P., Factors associated with serum thyroglobulin in Ukrainian cohort exposed to iodine-131 from the accident at the Chernobyl Nuclear Plant. Environ Res. 2017. Vol.156. Р.801-809.
Prasad K.N., Cole W.C., Hasse G.M. Health risks of low dose ionizing radiation in humans: a review. Exp Biol Med (Maywood).- 2004. Vol.229(5). Р.378-382.
Rahu K., Bromet E.J., Hakulinen T. et al. Noncancer morbidity among Estonian Chernobyl cleanup workers: a register-based cohort study. BMJ Open. 2014. Vol.4. e004516.
Ron E., Brenner A. Non-malignant thyroid diseases after a wide range of radiation exposures. Radiat Res. 2010. V.174 (6). P. 877-888.
Tharmalingam S., Sreetharan S., Kulesza A.V., Boreham D.R., Tai T.C. Low-Dose Ionizing Radiation Exposure, Oxidative Stress and Epigenetic Programing of Health and Disease. Radiat Res. 2017.188(4.2). P.525-538.
Stepanova I.I., Berezovs'kyĭ V.I., Kolpakov I.E., Kondrashova V.H., Lytvynets' O.M. Endothelium dependent vascular reactivity and autonomic homeostasis in children living in radiation-contaminated areas. Lik Sprava. 2013. Vol. (2). Р.32-38.
United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation. Sources and effects of ionizing radiation. UNSCEAR 2008 report to the General Assembly with scientific annexes, volume II, scientific annex D: health effects due to radiation from the Chernobyl accident. New York: United Nations, 2011
Bibliography link
Pivina L.M, Semenova Yu.M., Belikhina Т.I., Manatova А.М., Dyussupov A.A., Aukenov N.Е. Risk of disorders of nonspecific resistance due to long-term exposure to radiation in small doses. Nauka i Zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2017, 5, pp. 158-171