RATIONALE USE OF MEDICINES IN OUTPATIENT PRACTICE IN KAZAKHSTAN: ASSESSMENT OF WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION INDICATORS
Introduction: Rational use of medicines (RUM) is the cornerstone of safe, effective, and affordable outpatient care. We assessed how practices in Shymkent polyclinics align with WHO indicators.
Objective: To evaluate WHO indicators for prescribing and patient care in the outpatient setting and to identify variability requiring targeted improvements.
Materials and methods: A cross-sectional study based on WHO methodology (December 2024–April 2025) was conducted in 13 polyclinics. A total of 390 outpatient visits of patients were analyzed for patient-care indicators and 1300 prescriptions for prescribing indicators. Descriptive statistics, Welch’s ANOVA, and permutation χ²-tests were applied. Composite performance indices were constructed for benchmarking.
Results: The mean consultation duration was 13.5±6.2 minutes (range 3–35 across centers; p<0.001). Dispensing time averaged 205±139 seconds (45–960; p<0.001). On average, 94.4% of prescribed medicines were dispensed; 86.4% of patients correctly knew their dosages, both showing significant inter-center variation. An average of 1.8±0.9 medicines was prescribed per visit; 100% by INN and from the EML. Antibiotics were prescribed in 3.4% of visits (0–8% across centers; p=0.01). Injections were used in 24.5% of visits (low variability; p=0.992). Composite indices identified center 9 as best-performing in patient care and center 7 in prescribing; centers 2, 6, and 13 consistently lagged (e.g., in center 6 only 77% of medicines were dispensed, and dosage knowledge reached just 60%).
Conclusions: Outpatient care in Shymkent demonstrates strengths - low polypharmacy, universal INN prescribing, alignment with essential medicines, and relatively low antibiotic use. However, key challenges remain: wide variability in consultation and dispensing times, insufficient patient counseling, stock-outs of medicines in some centers, and persistently high injection prescribing. Priority measures: Standardization of consultation and dispensing processes, reduction of unnecessary injections through clinical protocols and provider training, strengthening of pharmaceutical counseling and patient education, and ensuring equitable medicine availability - especially in underperforming centers.
Number of Views: 68
Category of articles:
Original article
Bibliography link
Amirkhanova G.N., Yermukhanova Ly.S., Mussina A.Z., Dzhusupov K.O., Kimatova K.N., Nurbakyt A.N., Assylbekov N.A. Rationale use of medicines in outpatient practice in Kazakhstan: assessment of World Health Organization indicators // Nauka i Zdravookhranenie [Science & Healthcare]. 2025. Vol.27 (4), pp. 113-122. doi 10.34689/SH.2025.27.4.015Related publications:
GENETIC VARIANTS IN LIPID-ASSOCIATED GENES IN THE KAZAKHSTANI COHORT WITH ATHEROSCLEROSIS AND HYPERTRIGLYCERIDEMIA
CLONAL HEMATOPOIESIS WITH INDETERMINATE POTENTIAL IN TET2 AND DNMT3A AMONG KAZAKHSTANI INDIVIDUALS WITH ATHEROSCLEROTIC DISEASE
PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS AND ASSESSMENT OF THE HEALTH STATUS OF THE DESCENDANTS OF PERSONS EXPOSED TO RADIATION, LIVING IN THE BESKARAGAI DISTRICT OF THE ABAY REGION
PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS OF THE HEALTH STATUS AND RADIATION DOSES OF RESIDENTS OF THE ABAY DISTRICT OF THE ABAY REGION, WHO ARE DESCENDANTS OF PERSONS EXPOSED TO RADIATION DUE TO NUCLEAR WEAPONS TESTS
TRENDS AND DISPARITIES IN CANCER MORBIDITY IN KAZAKHSTAN: A REGIONAL AND AGE-BASED ANALYSIS FOR 2014-2024